Gandalf died in darkness, burned by the fire of the Balrog. Beyond that, it seemed to diminish the hope of the entire party because there was none among them that did not, at least, have intense respect for Gandalf. By losing Gandalf, someone he’s known for so long as a dear friend, Frodo’s soul is somewhat crushed and his eyes are opened more to the reality of his situation. Gandalf’s death was a pivotal moment for the story because it is when Frodo begins to realize that he is not only risking his own life, he’s risking his friends’ lives too. His commitment to the beings of Middle-earth is moving and admirable, which is what makes his death so difficult for characters and viewers alike. When he returns to Earth, his greatest contributions to it are the ones that we see in the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings tales.
From her he learned how to be empathetic and considerate of others- some of his best qualities that we see recurring throughout the story. In his time as Olorin, he was often revered by his fellow Maiar for his wisdom and spent much time with Nienna, who was a queen of the Valar that was gifted in the ways of mercy. The Maiar were beings created to assist the Valar in forging the Earth. Before he was even Gandalf the Grey, he was Olorin, a Maia. To fully understand this question, fans must first consider who Gandalf is, outside of his relevance to the ring. RELATED: LOTR: What Did Galadriel's Gifts To The Fellowship Of The Ring Mean? Others believe that the rebirth was an appropriate choice and that it contributes to the greater storyline, given the layers of Christian lore woven into the world. On one hand, some people view it as a cheat- an unrealistic solution to a hole in the story that Tolkien couldn’t figure out how to fill in another way. Since the emotional responses to these scenes were so different, many fans, writers, and scholars have argued whether or not the resurrection was actually necessary to the whole story. The Lord of the Rings trilogy evokes an array of emotions in viewers, with two of the most emotional moments being Gandalf’s death and his revival.